In Kata, Uke is in the Driver's Seat

Ever notice in the old pictures and videos of people doing Kata, Uke is often has the higher rank...  Ever wonder why that is?  Part of it is because Uke has a harder job than Tori...

You may  have already read my prior posts explaining that Uke has a job.   Nowhere is that more true than in Kata; in most Kata, Uke is responsible for the just about the whole thing.  Uke must...
  • ... create the right circumstances for Tori to execute the desired technique(s).   Uke dictates what throw is to be done by his movement and the other specifics of his attack.  Tori just has to recognize what Uke is "telling" her to do (via his attack), and then do it.  This is really really hard when you get into the finer distinctions...  So hard that I've not yet done it right (even approaching right) for an entire kata. (I'll post more about this in Nage no Kata later)
  • ... set the right spacing between partners.  This is really just a part of creating the right circumstances, but I'm calling it out separately because it happens "in-between" techniques.  In most Kata, Tori just picks a spot on the mat, and Uke then picks the best point from which to launch his attack.  Uke adjusts to Tori, not the other way around.  As a side note, if you are my Tori in a Kata practice, STOP MOVING!  I'm setting the distance I want, so when you inch towards me, I need to inch back.  =:>
  • ... remember the order in which the techniques are to be performed. By setting the spacing and generally moving first, and otherwise creating the right situation for the throw, Uke is really on the hook for remembering the order. In advanced Nage no Kata practice, Uke can intentionally screw up the order of techniques as a check on whether Tori is properly tuned in.
  • ... set the pace at which the Kata is to be performed.  If Uke goes fast, then Tori must go fast.  If Uke goes slow, then Tori should go slow.
  • ... set the mood.  No, not cranking up the Teddy Pendergrass and lighting candles.  I'm talking about creating the right frame of mind for the practice.  Focus, intensity, even the underlying intentions...  Sure, Uke is pushing Tori, but what is he trying to accomplish with this push?  This is really another sub-set of creating the right circumstances, but I wanted to call it out.
Of course, each Kata is different, so this stuff will be true to varying degrees depending on which Kata you are practicing.  I had Nage no Kata and Ju no Kata at top of mind when writing this, and I think every point above applies to those two Kata.  Spacing doesn't apply to Katame, and maybe not to the entirety of Itsutsu, and I don't have enough experience with the rest to say one way or the other.  But you should at least evaluate these dimensions when you are practicing Kata.

btemplates

5 comments:

Patrick Parker said...

that's right. traditionally in the old weapon arts, like kendo and kenjutsu and jodo, the attacker is the master.

This is because they were super-concerned with transmitting the cleanest, purest signal to the student as possible with the least possible noise.

kodokanjudo said...

In the few and rare judo film clips or in the early judo books, uke's role in kata is always done by someone like Nagaoka, Yokoyama or Yamashita. Tori's role was given to someone with less experience.
Kano-sensei seams to have been the only exception, as he was the shihan or founder of the art.

Chad Morrison said...

Pat, I like the signal/noise notion. I would add "most complete signal" as well...

kodokanjudo said...

Back in the late 80's, Daigo-sensei was involved in a kata "cross signal" incident.
He was the tori in a nage-no-kata demonstration at the Kodokan during one of the yearly celebrations, when his uke attacked for a right ura-nage instead of waiting for tori's push for a right tomoe-nage.
Daigo-sensei reacted with out any hesitation and after a left ura-nage was completed, he went back for tomoe-nage. Those that witnessed the event were amazed at his perfect reactions and follow up, many did not even realized the mistake until later comments by those that noticed.
It seams that Daigo-sensei read the "signal" well that day.

Chad Morrison said...

That's fantastic. That's the dream.